Many of you have noted the articles in various blogs discussing the “Royal Champions” of late. Specifically you have been reading about those among this group of selected web personalities who have spoken of cruises on Royal Caribbean without disclosing their status when posting to different forums. Some of you may be reading this and hearing of them for the first time. And at the risk of a massive and to many, boring post, I offer some background on the matter, and on the future of this websites.
Royal Caribbean hired a company to seek out people who spoke favorably of the line. These people were dubbed “Royal Champions.” There are presently estimated to be between 50 and 75 people whom are so named by the company. In 2007 a group of these people were invited to take a cruise on Liberty of the Seas, during her pre-inaugural schedule. I was one of those people. There were no strings attached to this cruise, and that was said in plan terms when I was called by way of my Crown and Anchor entry with the company.
Those invited were required to pay their own way to the ship, expenses while onboard, etc. A number of people within this group were invited to attend one of the Oasis of the Seas “reveals” in 2008. I was not among that group, though I might have been invited, I don’t recall.
More recently the entire group has been asked to update their personal information in what most regard as preparation for one or more events leading to the launch of Oasis. However, it is the cruise on Liberty of the Seas which is at the crux of the current hullabaloo.
To my personal knowledge there are people from many circles among the Royal Champions who were on Liberty. They include most notably, frequent and positive speaking posters from among the membership of Cruise Critic, a large cruise focused website I’m sure you all know well. I’ve more recently become absolutely certain that people from Cruise Mates, and several other forums were invited on the cruise, though it may not have been due to posts on those forums. Suffice to say however that the people on the cruise had access and use of every forum online. I was not invited as one of these people.
In addition, there were people sent on the cruise who were given the trip as a reward for contests as I recall. Some of these trips were given out by radio contests in New York City if memory servers. Also among the group were select blog writers, posters to the ancient Usenet group Rec.Travel.Cruises, and yours truly. The ship was also full of Crown and Anchor members of mostly Diamond level or higher, not all of whom I’ve learned were happy to have others aside from the many travel agents and VIPs aboard.
As to those who became known as Royal Champions, their going was well known to the online community at the time, and it was all very exciting as I recall. It did spur questions as to how folks were selected at the time, and the running discussions lead many people to suddenly attempt to woo attention by “talking-up” Royal Caribbean as they assumed was needed to “join” the groups being talked about. That behavior has persisted to present day, and frankly it is one reason I simply gave-up on reading several forums more than once a year on average.
I was confused about how exactly I was invited until a reception aboard ship when I had a chance to shake a few hands, make a few contacts. In talking to several people aboard, it seems I may have been something of a novelty. I am not sure if I stand as unique, but I did not meet any other person who was the owner and operator of a website akin to this. The cruise was to me a great validation of the years of hard work I had already put into Royal Caribbean Fan, and has very much inspired me to redouble my efforts to improve the site.
So we come now to more recent months. A note went out to people who had been among those “Royal Champions” asking for updated contact information. The comments posted online mentioning this lead to broader questions as to what “Royal Champions” were, and what they did. This lead some consumer issues blogs and others to find an old entry on the website of the marketing company that developed the first list of champions. The result has been that an ugly mess has spilled into the blogs and online forums about “Royal Champions.”
The main thrust of the critical comments is in the feeling that people in this group mislead people online by posting reviews of their trip. Or that subsequent comments were intended to curry favor with Royal Caribbean. Likewise, the line itself is being attacked for the program itself. What will come of it for the events that involve Royal Champions is hard to say. I’ve observed there are a surprisingly large number of people who simply did not know they were even part of the program. And these were people actually on the ship in 07. The fuss also seems to be about something that is as common a practice in many industries as you can count, and has been stirred up mainly due to a few people being over zealous and people be jealous.
For my part, you know what you get when visiting a website called Royal Caribbean Fan. I was proud of being invited on the cruise I took, and hope to have the chance to do it again. I dislike the idea of not telling folks that a given trip or cruise was taken for free, or whatever else might prove to be the case. How, if at all, will this impact how I do things here? To begin with, I am going to alter the Terms of Service to require people reviewing a cruise to disclose if they were receiving that cruise in exchange for some form of consideration.
Moving forward, I do expect to partner with travel agents and companies to aid in building the size of our community. I expect these partnerships to take several forms, and what I or the site gains from it will vary. The most immediate project will be to provide promotional cards about this site to willing agents and business’. The purpose being simply to aid in developing a growing base of users. Some degree of reciprocal promotion is possible here, and the degree I allow that will depend.
Next, I have been asked by several travel agents, about the idea of promoting cruises they are organizing, on this site. I don’t want this site to become overwhelmed with promotions, so how many people I form partnerships with will depend. What I do for these cruises, and the consideration given in return may vary as well. I expect that if a group cruise promoted on this site were to sell-out, I may receive some discount, large or small should I be able to go myself. The site may gain direct promotion to the people booking on these cruises through their agent, for which I may also create forum areas for those groups to discuss their trips.
I do plan to expand my territory online, which will mean a few things. First, I’ll be adding some other projects, such as Cruise Aficionados and Cruise Travel Gear, to touch on other areas of the industry that I don’t want to mix with Royal Caribbean Fan.
Lastly, I intend to offer my services to travel agents and other business’ which might want to bolster their own web operations. Times being what they are, to not take advantage of my skills seems nuts.
In the end, this site is my baby, and I intend to walk softly and treat it well.